Use Popow in your AI

  1. 1Copy the install prompt

    Set up Popow with automatic plugin updates: https://github.com/popow-ai/plugin/blob/main/install.md
  2. 2Paste it into Claude or ChatGPT

Creator Marketing Playbooks

Should you put earned media value in your campaign report?

Half of the figure is a rate you supply, and what you supply fixes what it can be asked.

Two inputs, and you set one of them.

You sell a countertop compost bin — the kind people buy because the kitchen bin starts to smell by Wednesday. Four creator videos you paid for went up on the creators' own accounts last month. The quarterly review is Thursday, and the reporting template that came back has a line on it you have not filled in before: earned media value (EMV).

Put it in when somebody has written down that they want to know what this exposure would have cost to buy, and written it before the number goes in front of them. That is the question the figure answers. It is not a result, and nothing on the page tells you whether it lines up with another brand's.

For the compost bin: nobody has written anything down yet. The line is on the template because the template has it.

What is the figure made of?

Two inputs, and you set one of them.

One competitor's guide to earned media value gives both the formula it calls the most common one and the way to fill it in. The figure is "Calculated by multiplying impressions from 3rd party sources by a set CPM", which it writes out as "EMV = ( Total impressions / 1,000 ) X CPM". The impressions are what the four posts did. The CPM is the half that guide tells you to pick: "The best way to determine a CPM to calculate your EMV is to take the equivalent rate you would pay using paid ads and adding a premium / markup of around 50% -100 %." The guide's reason for any markup at all is its own argument, and it says so in its own voice — "We argue that an impression received from an influencer recommending a product is worth a lot more compared to an impression received by an interruptive ad while someone is scrolling their feed."

So the top of that range prices each thousand at twice what you pay for ads and the bottom at one and a half times. The guide writes the band as approximate; even at its edges it puts the top a third above the bottom, while the four videos sit exactly where they were. The same guide adds another number of the same kind when the figure is used to forecast rather than report, recommending "taking a discount on this rate to account for risk as well as for slightly depressed reach due to sponsored content." — a reason the same paragraph then partly withdraws, since it allows that a well-made sponsored post can go further than the average.

Our guide to paying a creator per thousand views separates the two jobs the letters do: "In a report, it can describe what you spent per thousand impressions. In a payment offer, a per-thousand rate can determine what you owe." This report is a third use, and that guide does not take it up. You did not buy impressions at a CPM, and you do not owe one. The rate is assigned to them afterwards, by you, which is what lets you read your own choice back out of the figure.

For the compost bin: the four videos produced one number between them, and nobody in the review has said yet what the brand pays per thousand for its own ads. That unspoken rate is the half you would be choosing.

So what question does the figure answer?

One: the price of buying that exposure — and only the version with no markup on it answers even that.

The same competitor guide puts it plainly — the figure "provides an estimate of what it would cost to achieve the same level of visibility through paid advertising" — and the room it names is a budget one, though it names it for a forecast rather than a report: "If you are considering partnering with an influencer it might be useful to forecast an expected EMV so you can make a case with finance to request the budget." On the reporting side that guide does not want the line standing alone: "Only looking at EMV could lead to difficulties if not analyzed alongside other metrics such as conversions."

Those two sentences do not sit together. An estimate of what the exposure would have cost to buy is your own paid rate times the count. The method puts half again or double on top of that, and a figure two times the ad cost is not an estimate of the ad cost — it is that guide's price for the exposure. Reading the two against each other is ours, not a rule that guide states: it recommends the markup and the ad-cost description in the same document and leaves them as they are.

The choice behind the question has two sides priced in different units: ad money buys thousands of impressions at a rate you already know, and video money buys videos. Something has to put them on one scale, and this figure is one way. The measure the per-thousand-views guide names for a report — what you spent per thousand impressions — is another, and that one needs no rate from you at all. What EMV adds over it is that it prices the exposure rather than the purchase. What it costs you is the rate you had to supply.

For the compost bin: finance is choosing between running ads for another month and booking four more videos.

What does it not answer?

Two things a dollar figure looks like it would settle, and doesn't.

Whether the videos did their job. Our guide to telling whether a creator video worked answers that question from a different place: "The answer is in your own notes, or it doesn't exist." It is specific about why the number under the post cannot stand in: "The count doesn't know what you hired the video to do." The arithmetic adds a price and no information about the sentence each video had to land.

How it compares with anybody else's. The competitor guide is explicit about why in its own drawbacks section: "EMV lacks a universal calculation formula, leading to inconsistencies across brands and campaigns. Different marketers use varying metrics like CPM or engagement rates, making comparisons difficult." Two figures line up only when the formula and the rate behind them are stated and the same, which is not how they arrive. The same drawbacks section attaches two more conditions in the same breath. The figure is a proxy that does not link directly to sales or revenue, and the guide's own consequence for that is "Brands might see high EMV figures without seeing proportional business results, making it harder to justify the metric." The price it puts on the exposure can also overstate it: "Assigning a monetary value to organic mentions can sometimes overestimate their actual impact."

None of that is a guide arguing against the metric. It recommends EMV and lists what it is good for earlier in the same guide. The drawbacks are the conditions it attaches.

There is a shape to this that we have met before on a different metric. Our guide to comparing creators by engagement rate found three published formulas for one percentage in one competitor's guide to calculating engagement rate on TikTok, said "Three isn't the whole range either.", and drew the reader's attention to the input rather than the result: "A figure you can't line up is still a figure with a question attached, and the question is what it was divided by." Here the axis flips — what it was multiplied by — and that flip is ours, not that article's. The instruction survives the flip because it is about reading the input, not about division. That same article of ours also says "look at what the column is made of before you sort it", and a column of EMV figures from four different reports may have a separately chosen rate behind each one, with nothing on the page to tell you.

That article of ours stops short of calling such a figure worthless, and this one stops in the same place: "None of which makes a percentage you can't line up worthless." A figure that cannot be compared can still answer the question it was built for.

Sitting with a report line nobody can trace? Bring the campaign and we'll work through what it can be asked. Book a demo →

Where do the impressions come from?

The half you did not choose is not handed to you either.

The competitor guide calls Instagram the harder case because, it says, the view figures for feed and story posts are not public there. Its instruction for that case is to go and ask: "In this case the best way to create your report is to ask the influencers for a screenshot of their analytics after the campaign." That ask is its own job, and our guide to asking a creator for the numbers only they can see is exact about what comes back: "It's a screenshot: a picture of a screen, taken by the person whose screen it is. It shows one thing, on one day, and nothing else is retrievable from it later."

Where that count is public, what it counts is still an open question. The competitor guide's reason for calling the other platforms the easy ones is the publicness itself — "On TikTok and Youtube on the other hand the impressions are public making it easier to compute your EMV calculations." Our guide to telling whether a video worked declines to say what that public counter counts: "The public count alone does not establish how many unique people watched." Obtainable and defined are not the same thing, and the per-thousand-views guide separates the words themselves: "Views and impressions are different metrics, so the letters alone do not name the number in the agreement." That sentence rules on a payment agreement, and a report is not one. What carries here is the distinction rather than the ruling: the formula asks for one of those two words and gets filled from whichever figure the platform shows.

For the compost bin: three of the four posts are on TikTok and one is on Instagram. Three figures that guide treats as public, one screenshot it tells you to go and ask for, and one footnote you now owe the report about which figures came from where. The ask is that guide's instruction rather than something you can count on, and our own guide to asking for those numbers puts a late one in its own class: "A message sent once the video is already up is a favor, and a favor is fine, but you can't plan around one."

When does it belong in the report?

When the sentence exists.

Our guide to giving a creator a discount code wrote the rule for a number you are about to go and get: "Give it for the name when you can say in advance what you'd do differently depending on what the number says. Write that sentence down before any discount code is issued. If it doesn't exist, the number will arrive and nothing will happen." The guide to putting a call to action in a creator video then applies the same rule beyond the code: "Whatever instrument you use, the same rule applies before you issue anything".

Nothing about an EMV line gets issued. Our guide to running a giveaway with a creator has already made this move with a number of the same kind, and it says what transfers: "A follower count is not an instrument at all, so what carries over is the demand rather than the authority." The demand is the sentence. Write it and see whether it changes anything.

For the compost bin: two sentences get drafted. If the number is big, we'll do more of this conditions nothing that is still open — next quarter's campaign is signed off and the creators already have their dates, so a big number would start nothing and a small one would stop nothing. Finance is choosing between another ad month and four more videos, so we'll put last month's exposure on the same scale as the CPM we pay for ads is a different kind of sentence. It names the decision, and the decision is the one the figure is built for.

Then the second sentence tells you what to do before Thursday rather than after it. The rate is the half you supply, so agree it with the person reading the report while the question is still open: your own paid CPM, and whether a markup goes on top of it. On the reading above, an ad-cost sentence answers the second one for you. Settle the rest in the room and the figure sits on a rate both sides accepted. Settle it at your desk on Wednesday night and you have handed finance a number that moves with a decision you made alone.

Frequently asked questions

Our agency's report already has an EMV line. What do we do with it?

Ask which formula made it and which two numbers went into that formula, because neither is recoverable from the amount. The competitor guide's own objection — that there is no universal formula and that marketers use "varying metrics like CPM or engagement rates" — applies to a line you were handed just as much as to one you would compute. Two agencies' figures are not on one scale, and two quarters of your own are not either: holding the rate still leaves the other half, and that half reaches each quarter's report through a different mix of public counts and screenshots. What a held rate buys is a change of units rather than a second finding, so the line earns its place only where somebody wrote down that they wanted the exposure priced that way.

Can we use it to work out what a creator is worth before we book them?

That is the forecast the competitor guide describes, and it runs on three inputs rather than two: the average views that creator's recent videos have been getting, your chosen CPM, and then that recommended discount for risk. The average is theirs and sits under the same question the reported count does. The rate and the discount are yours, so the output carries the limit the reported version carries. What a creator should be paid is a different question with its own answers: what to pay a creator attaches the number to the parts of the job you settled, and when to pay per thousand views covers the case where a count determines the bill.

See what this looks like for your brand

Got a reporting line you are not sure you can defend? Bring last quarter's campaign and we'll go through it with you. Book a demo →

Or email us: business@popow.ai

Ready to run this with creators?

See how Popow briefs, matches, and ships TikTok-native content for your campaign.

Book a demo →business@popow.ai