Creator Marketing Playbooks
Should you run a giveaway with a creator?
The prize is product you already own, so the proposal reads as free. What a giveaway spends is the post you already bought.
You sell a sleep mask with a curved cup over each eye, so it sits on the bone instead of on the eyelids. One creator is booked, filming is next week, and the brief has one sentence in it that everything else was built around: after seeing this, the viewer should understand that the mask leaves room to blink instead of pressing on your eyes, and see it sit flat with no gap at the nose.
Then the creator comes back with an idea. Make it a giveaway. They post the video, and anyone who follows your account and tags a friend is entered to win a mask.
Nobody in the room is against it. The prize is a mask, and you have masks. Somebody says the follower count will move. What nobody has said is what happens to the sentence.
What is the proposal changing?
Three things change, and the prize is only the first of them.
The sentence you wrote is the thing you hired the video to do. Our guide to telling whether a creator video worked puts it in a form the brief already uses — "One sentence about the viewer, in a form you already use: after seeing this, the viewer should …" — and it has "Two parts: something to understand, something to see." For the mask, the understanding is that it leaves room to blink; the seeing is it lying flat at the nose. One post has to carry both.
A giveaway puts a second offer in that post. One competitor's guide to running giveaways with creators tells brands to choose a prize that captures the attention of the audience they want and to keep the entry requirements straightforward, and it says the point of the exercise is "to bring over the followers of an influencer to your business page". That guide is written for Instagram, its own goal is a bigger follower count, and it makes no claim about what happens to your sentence. Set its instructions beside yours, though, and the arithmetic is ours to do: the prize is a reason to watch that competes with yours, and the entry is the thing to do.
So the post now has two offers in it, and one of them is a free mask. That is the first change, and it is the one to name before anyone argues about whether giveaways work. The second is what comes back from the post. The third is what leaves your shelf to pay for the prize.
Where is the entry requirement pointing?
Two places at once — and neither of the tests you already use decides this one.
Follow the brand account finishes somewhere outside the video. Our guide to putting a call to action in a creator video names exactly that shape — "A call to action (CTA): a line that asks the viewer to do something once the video is over." — and gives it two questions: "Is there somewhere for it to go?" and "Is it yours to state?" with "Neither answer can be no." Your account exists today and its handle is a fact at your company, so both answers are yes. The follow half passes.
Tag a friend finishes under the post, in the comment window below it. The CTA guide puts that half outside its own ruling, not outside its two questions: "an ask for something that happens where the video already is, like a reply under it, is a different question this piece doesn't take up." The guide that takes it up is asking viewers to comment, and it ran those same two questions on an ask that finishes under the post — "its two questions are about a destination, and this ask has one. So you can still run them on it" — and said where that leaves you: "Neither question stops it, and neither asks who the window belongs to."
So neither question stops either half, and that is not what decides this. That guide settles its own case on something else — "whether this campaign is asking people to believe something only you can stand behind" — and it says that this question is "asked about the campaign instead of about the line." So that test is available here in principle. We are not using it, because it decides whether a line asking for comments earns a place in a brief, and what you are deciding is whether to change what the post is for.
So what this settles is narrow: neither guide tells you to take the proposal or refuse it. What decides it is what comes back from those two places.
What arrives, and can you read it afterwards?
Follows arrive, and they arrive anonymous.
The CTA guide sets the condition for a named arrival: "An arrival can only carry a name if the video handed out something that names it." A mask is not something that names an arrival. One viewer wins it, and the prize says nothing about where any of the others came from — hand one to every viewer and that is still true. So by that condition the follows carry no name. How the platform records a follow is not something we have checked, and it doesn't have to be: nothing went out that could name a follow.
That doesn't settle it by itself, because a number that moves can still be worth having. Our guide to giving a creator a discount code wrote the rule for that case: "Give it for the name when you can say in advance what you'd do differently depending on what the number says. Write that sentence down before any discount code is issued. If it doesn't exist, the number will arrive and nothing will happen." The instrument there is a discount code, and the CTA guide already carried that rule past the one instrument it was written for: "Whatever instrument you use, the same rule applies before you issue anything." A follower count is not an instrument at all, so what carries over is the demand rather than the authority. Try writing the sentence for the followers. The CTA guide ran that exercise on a campaign of its own and concluded "nothing goes out for the name."
For the mask: the team drafts two candidates. The first threatens to stop something: the next campaign is scoped and the creator is booked, so there is nothing the low number would stop. The second promises another giveaway if the number is high, which commits the brand to more of the thing whose value is the open question. Both are sentences. Neither one changes a decision, so the follower count is not a reason to run this.
What was that comment window for?
It is where you read whether the sentence landed, and it is the only such place anyone outside your company can see. Our guide to telling whether a creator video worked sorts what you can check into piles and names that one: "On the video's page. The count and every comment under it, public, in the words the viewer chose." The others sit in your own records, or in the pile that guide says nobody can settle.
The window isn't something the giveaway creates or the brand owns. Our guide to replying to comments on a creator's video says where the window under a creator's post came from: "The comment window under it came with the post. It was there yesterday for their last video, and it'll be there next week for the one after yours."
What it gives you is a reading. The video-worked guide uses it for exactly that — "It tells you what people think they watched." — and sorts what you find into three kinds:
- "Questions about using the product."
- "Descriptions of the product that get it wrong."
- "Comments about the creator and nothing else."
Each one reads on your sentence differently, and that guide supplies the reading for all three. A question about using the mask puts the viewer past the blinking claim and into their own bedroom. A wrong description means the claim "didn't survive the watching." And a comment about the creator alone means "It read as one of their posts, and your sentence never reached them."
An entry is none of the three, and putting it outside them is our call rather than that guide's — it never had entries to sort. Tagged my sister, fingers crossed is not a statement about the mask, a description of it, or a remark about the creator. It is the entry requirement being performed. The entries don't delete the other comments, and some people will do both. What changes is the pile you read: the statements you were looking for are now mixed in with entries, and the better the giveaway does, the more there is to read past.
That is the part of the trade the proposal didn't price. The masks come off a shelf somebody will reconcile. The reading doesn't.
Where does the prize come from?
Off your inventory. Which budget line it comes out of is a question this campaign has not had to answer.
Our guide to how much product to set aside for a creator campaign counts two factors, sends and units per send, and the number of sends is the one in question here: "So the number you're setting is a number of sends." A send goes to a creator, and the unit is gone either way — "Paid or unpaid, the unit is off your inventory the day it ships." A prize goes to a viewer, so it is not one of the sends that guide is counting, and it isn't a unit inside one either.
It isn't the creator's pay either, and the guide to sending a creator free product instead of paying them is about product that goes to the creator throughout. The test it gives separates a send you attached an ask to from one you didn't — "the way to tell which you did is to read what you wrote. If a sentence in it names something you want back, you asked" — and both ends of that test are the creator. A mask going to a stranger who tagged a friend is neither of its two sends.
So the prize sits outside both counts, and that is the whole finding here. This guide doesn't pick the line for you. What it does say is that the question is open before the campaign starts, because the alternative is finding out at the end of the month that the masks left the shelf against a number that was set for sends.
So should you run one?
Two conditions, and a third case where both of them apply.
Run it when a follower count is what you wrote down. Not when it would be nice, and not when the prize is cheap — when the thing you put in writing before anyone proposed a giveaway was a number of followers, and the naming sentence from the discount-code guide holds up once you write it. Then the post is doing the job you set for it, the entries are the mechanism rather than a cost, and the window crowding with tags takes nothing from you, because you were never going to read it for the brief's sentence.
Keep it out when the brief's sentence is what you're buying. If the brief was built around what the viewer should understand and see, a giveaway puts a free mask in front of that sentence and then crowds the one public place you would have read it in. You don't get a smaller version of that by asking for a smaller prize, because the prize is what makes people perform the entry requirement, and the entry requirement is what crowds the window.
When both are written down, the giveaway makes you choose. A brief can carry a sentence and a follower count at the same time, and then both conditions fire. The entries that move the follower count are the same entries you would be reading past, so the post serves one of the two well and the other badly. That is the choice the giveaway forces: pick which of the two this post is for, and write the other one down for a different post. Either way, settle where the prize comes off your shelf before the campaign starts — that line stays open whichever condition you act on.
For the mask: the sentence is the whole campaign — the brief has the blinking claim and the flat-at-the-nose shot in it, and nobody wrote a follower count anywhere. The naming sentence collapsed on the first try. So the giveaway stays out, the video gets made the way it was briefed, and the idea goes in the file for the next campaign, where somebody might write the follower count down first.
Frequently asked questions
The creator wants to run the giveaway on their own account, with a prize they bought. Is that still our campaign?
What you bought settles this, and our guide to what to settle with a creator before the shoot owns those terms. Our guide to asking viewers to comment sends the same shape there: "Whether a further post is inside what you bought belongs with the things you agree before the shoot". So the answer is in what you agreed. The CTA guide reaches the same place from a line that points somewhere that isn't yours, and says what you have when the agreement doesn't cover it: "what you have is a conversation with the creator rather than a note on the draft."
The prize changes nothing about that, and it does change one thing on this page. Nothing comes off your shelf, so the open line from the prize question closes on its own. The sentence and the window are where they were.
Does the disclosure line in the brief change because it's a giveaway?
That line belongs to our guide to what belongs in a creator brief, which treats it as its own kind of line — "Disclosure is a facts line, and the strictest one on the list." — and it is the only line on that list where getting it wrong "isn't a campaign problem." That guide links the FTC's own material and tells you to read it yourself and ask a lawyer when the stakes are real.
Whether giveaways and contests carry requirements of their own is something this guide hasn't checked, and it isn't saying either way. That one sits with a lawyer, and it is worth answering before the post goes up.
See what this looks like for your brand
Or email us: business@popow.ai